Not So Colorful Monsters Black and White Finger Monsters: the black and white version of Archie McPhee’s world-famous Finger Monsters! It’s what they might have looked like if they starred in a silent movie. These are less garish and way classier than regular Finger Monsters. Finger Monsters For Your Film Noir Needs Measuring 2″ tall each, these Black and White Finger Monsters are made from soft rubber and come in eight ghastly styles. Monsters are sold individually (1 a piece).